Copycat Starbucks Cake Pops: The Sweet Secret Behind the Popular Treat

Craving that soft, bite-sized Starbucks cake pop but don’t feel like waiting in line (or paying $3 for one)? You’re not alone. These adorable little desserts have become one of Starbucks’ most irresistible treats. But here’s the thing—they’re surprisingly easy to make at home. In this article, we’ll walk you through everything you need to know to recreate Copycat Starbucks Cake Pops in your own kitchen.

We’ll break down the ingredients, the techniques, the tools, and the flavors that make Starbucks cake pops so addictively good. Whether you’re a home baker looking to impress or a cake pop lover just trying to save a few bucks, this guide is your ticket to dessert heaven.

1. What Are the Ingredients of Starbucks Cake Pops?

The Basic Cake Pop Formula (Cake + Frosting + Coating)

Starbucks cake pops start with a moist cake interior made from crumbled cake mixed with frosting, then dipped in a candy coating. At its core, this is all it takes:

• Baked vanilla or chocolate cake (homemade or boxed mix)
• Creamy frosting (usually vanilla buttercream or cream cheese)
• Candy melts or chocolate coating (white or colored)
• Lollipop sticks
• Sprinkles or toppings (optional, but highly encouraged)

Pro Tip: For the closest copycat results, use a dense cake like pound cake. This gives the inside that rich, doughy texture Starbucks fans love.

Flavor Variations You Can Try

Starbucks changes its cake pop flavors seasonally, and so can you:

• Birthday Cake: Vanilla cake + pink candy melts + rainbow sprinkles
• Chocolate: Chocolate cake + chocolate frosting + dark coating
• Cookies & Cream: White cake + crushed Oreos + white chocolate shell

Use your imagination—and your pantry.

2. What Brand of Cake Pops Does Starbucks Use?

A Peek Behind the Curtain: Who Supplies Starbucks Cake Pops?

Most people don’t realize this, but Starbucks doesn’t actually bake their own cake pops in-store. They’re made by an outside supplier: SROriginals, now known as Steven Charles – A Dessert Company. This Colorado-based company produces the cake pops and delivers them ready-to-eat.

This means your local barista isn’t baking—they’re just unwrapping and serving. That’s why making your own at home not only saves you money but gives you full control over the quality and ingredients.

Why Their Brand Stands Out

Steven Charles uses:

• High-fat butter for richness
• Premium cocoa and vanilla extracts
• Tempered chocolate coatings for a smooth shell
• Precision portioning and freezing techniques

You may not have industrial equipment, but by using real butter, high-quality chocolate, and chilling your pops before dipping, you’ll get very close to the real thing.

Learn more about delicious homemade coatings in this article: Chocolate & Coated Treats

3. What Is the Trick to Making Cake Pops?

The Moisture Game: Get It Just Right

The number one mistake people make with cake pops? Adding too much frosting. This makes them soggy, sticky, or fall off the stick. You only need enough frosting to bind the crumbs. A good rule is:

• 1 cup of cake crumbs to 1-2 tablespoons of frosting

The mixture should resemble playdough: firm but pliable, not sticky.

The Freezer Is Your Friend

Want clean, professional results? Freeze your shaped balls for 15–30 minutes before dipping. This helps the coating set faster and prevents crumbs from falling into your chocolate.

Use a piece of styrofoam or an upside-down egg carton to hold the pops upright as they set.

Dipping Without Cracking

Another common issue is cracking once the coating hardens. That happens when the cake pop is too cold and the coating is too hot. Avoid this by:

• Letting the balls sit out for 5 minutes after freezing
• Cooling your candy melts slightly before dipping

Looking for candy melts and coating tips? Discover our guide on Gummies & Chews

Tools That Make a Difference

You don’t need fancy tools, but these help:

• A cookie scoop (for even-sized pops)
• Microwave-safe bowls
• Candy melt squeeze bottles or spoons
• Lollipop sticks (6-inch is standard)
• Sprinkles, glitter, or drizzle for decoration

4. Are Starbucks Cake Pops Cooked?

Yes, the Cake Is Baked First

This might sound obvious, but let’s clear up the confusion—Starbucks cake pops are fully cooked. The base of the cake pop is baked cake that’s later crumbled and mixed with frosting to form those rich, dense balls we all love.

So even though the texture feels moist and almost dough-like, it’s not raw at all. It’s fully baked, cooled, crumbled, and remixed.

How Copycat Versions Stay Safe to Eat

When making DIY cake pops at home, just make sure to:

• Bake your cake all the way through (use a toothpick test)
• Allow it to cool completely before crumbling
• Mix only with fresh frosting
• Refrigerate or freeze before serving to keep everything firm and food-safe

This method ensures your homemade version is just as safe and satisfying as Starbucks’.

Shelf Life and Storage Tips

Wondering how long your homemade cake pops will last? Here’s a quick chart:

Storage Method	Shelf Life
Room Temperature	2–3 days
Refrigerator	5–7 days
Freezer (wrapped)	Up to 1 month

Always store them in an airtight container to prevent the coating from sweating or cracking.

5. What Makes Starbucks Cake Pops So Good?

The Texture Combo

The number one reason people are obsessed with Starbucks cake pops? It’s the texture. That soft, rich, doughy inside contrasted with the crisp shell is just unbeatable.

This contrast comes from two things:

1. The crumb-to-frosting ratio—just enough moisture to bind, not enough to be mushy
2. Chilling before dipping—it makes the shell set faster and crisper

Homemade cake pops often go wrong by being too dry or too wet. Starbucks found the sweet spot—and now you can too.

The Visual Appeal

It’s not just about flavor. Starbucks cake pops look irresistible. They’re:

• Uniformly round
• Smoothly coated
• Dipped in pretty pastel or chocolate finishes
• Topped with sprinkles or swirls

To get that professional finish at home:

• Use candy melts in vibrant colors
• Add just a touch of vegetable shortening or coconut oil to thin the melt
• Dip in one smooth motion, then twirl gently to drip off excess

Flavor Boosters That Make a Difference

Want your copycat Starbucks cake pops to actually taste better than the real thing? Try these tips:

• Add a touch of espresso powder to chocolate cake for depth
• Use real vanilla bean paste instead of extract
• Try almond or coconut flavorings for seasonal twists
• Dip in dark chocolate for a richer shell

And for toppings? Crushed nuts, coconut flakes, gold dust, or edible glitter can add flavor and flair.

6. How to Make Starbucks Cake Pops at Home

Step-by-Step Process for Perfect Cake Pops

Ready to start making your own Starbucks-style cake pops? Here’s a step-by-step guide you can follow with any flavor combo:

1: Bake the Cake

Use a boxed cake mix or your favorite scratch recipe. Let it cool completely.

2: Crumble and Mix

Crumble the cake finely in a large bowl. Add frosting a tablespoon at a time and mix until it holds together like dough.

3: Roll and Chill

Use a cookie scoop to portion out the mix. Roll into tight balls and chill in the freezer for 15–30 minutes.

4: Melt and Dip

Melt candy melts according to the package. Dip each lollipop stick in chocolate before inserting into the cake ball (this helps it stay in place). Then dip the whole pop and twirl gently.

5: Decorate and Set

Top with sprinkles or drizzle. Stand upright in a foam block or egg carton until fully set.

Bonus Tips from Starbucks Fans

• For extra smooth coating: Add a spoon of shortening or coconut oil to thin the melts
• To prevent slipping: Freeze the balls longer or use a deeper dipping container
• To match Starbucks’ flavor: Use vanilla cake + buttercream + pink melts + rainbow sprinkles

Why DIY Wins

Making your own copycat cake pops saves money (less than 50 cents per pop), gives you more creative control, and adds a fun twist to any birthday party, shower, or bake sale.

7. Creative Variations of Copycat Starbucks Cake Pops

Seasonal Flavors That Wow

Why settle for just one flavor? One of the best things about making cake pops at home is how easy it is to customize. Take inspiration from Starbucks’ rotating seasonal menu or come up with your own:

Season	Cake Pop Ideas
Fall	Pumpkin spice cake + cream cheese frosting + white chocolate shell
Winter	Red velvet cake + vanilla frosting + peppermint sprinkles
Spring	Lemon cake + raspberry buttercream + pastel pink coating
Summer	Coconut cake + pineapple glaze + toasted coconut topping

Each of these combinations adds a festive flair to your dessert table.

Kid-Friendly & Themed Designs

Birthday parties? Baby showers? Holidays? Cake pops are easy to theme using colors, sprinkles, and molds:

• Use edible eyes for monster cake pops
• Make hearts for Valentine’s Day
• Add gold dust for a bridal shower

Starbucks may keep it simple, but at home, you can go wild with creativity.

Alternative Diet Versions

If you or your guests have dietary needs, try these:

• Gluten-free cake mix
• Vegan frosting (made with plant-based butter)
• Sugar-free candy melts

The result? Everyone gets to enjoy your copycat Starbucks cake pops, no matter their diet.

8. Tips for Selling Homemade Cake Pops

Is There a Market for Cake Pops? Absolutely.

These treats aren’t just fun to eat—they’re profitable. With Starbucks charging $2.95+ per pop, homemade cake pops can be a great side hustle or bakery item.

Getting Started: What You Need

• Business license (check local cottage food laws)
• Clear packaging (cellophane bags, twist ties, and labels)
• A menu of flavors and pricing
• Eye-catching photos for social media or a website

Start by selling to friends, then expand through local events, farmers markets, or Instagram.

Pricing Strategy

Here’s a simple way to price:

• Materials (cake, frosting, coating, sticks)
• Time (labor per dozen)
• Packaging costs
• Profit margin (usually 30–50%)

For example, if it costs $5 to make a dozen, you can sell them for $18–24 per dozen.

Looking for inspiration? Try our tips for homemade candy in Homemade Candy Ideas

Marketing Tips That Work

• Post cake pop videos on TikTok or Instagram
• Offer holiday specials (e.g., Halloween monster pops)
• Run giveaways to boost engagement
• Partner with local coffee shops for pop-ups

9. Common Mistakes and How to Fix Them

Too Much Frosting

This turns your cake pops into mush. Stick to the 1:1 ratio rule: 1 cup of crumbs to 1–2 tbsp frosting. The mixture should form a dough, not a paste.

Falling Off the Stick

Make sure to:

• Dip the stick in coating before inserting it
• Chill balls before dipping
• Don’t handle too much after dipping

Cracked Coating

That’s from extreme temperature differences. Let cake balls sit for 5–10 minutes after freezing before dipping. Also, don’t overheat the coating.

Lumpy or Streaky Finish

Use high-quality candy melts and thin them with coconut oil. Stir gently and don’t over-dip.

Uneven Shape

Use a cookie scoop to portion equally. Roll between your palms gently for smooth, round balls.

FAQ

What are the ingredients of Starbucks cake pops?

Starbucks cake pops are made with crumbled baked cake, frosting (often vanilla or chocolate buttercream), a hard candy melt coating, and decorative toppings. The texture is soft and rich, balanced by a firm outer shell.

What brand of cake pops does Starbucks use?

Starbucks sources its cake pops from Steven Charles (formerly SROriginals), a premium dessert manufacturer. These are pre-made and shipped to stores nationwide.

What is the trick to making cake pops?

The trick is mastering the frosting ratio, chilling the balls before dipping, and using smooth, thinned candy melts. Freeze the pops briefly before coating to get that perfect finish.

Are Starbucks cake pops cooked?

Yes, they’re made from fully baked cake, then crumbled and mixed with frosting. Despite their soft texture, there’s no raw batter in them.

What makes Starbucks cake pops so good?

It’s the texture—dense and moist inside with a crisp shell outside. The high-quality ingredients, fun flavors, and polished presentation also make them stand out.

Conclusion

By now, you’re more than ready to take on your own batch of copycat Starbucks cake pops. Whether you want to mimic the iconic birthday cake flavor or create your own twist, you’ve got the tools, tips, and tricks to nail it.

Not only is making cake pops fun, but it’s also a sweet way to save money, wow your guests, and even start your own business. So grab that cake mix, melt some chocolate, and get dipping.

Looking for more Halloween inspiration? Try our The Magic of Soft Christmas Peppermints before they vanish into the night.

For more recipes follow me on PINTEREST

Print